Sunday Edition · September 21 – September 27, 2026 · Late-summer recess · FY 2027 week four

Deadline · Dec 31, 2029

Cool Every Cell

0 Facilities

After an eight-day bench trial in Austin, U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman ordered the Texas Department of Criminal Justice to install air conditioning in every state prison no later than December 31, 2029 — finding that extreme heat in uncooled units violates the Eighth Amendment and that TDCJ's mitigation measures fall short. Only about one-third of TDCJ's 104 facilities were fully air conditioned when the order issued on September 22.

No. 1:23-CV-1004-RP Eighth Amendment Sep 22 Findings entered
0%

Fully air conditioned · Sep 1 baseline

Criminal justice · Conditions litigation

Heat as punishment

Plaintiffs led by Texas Citizens United for Rehabilitation of Errants argued that indoor heat indices routinely exceed safe thresholds — a claim Pitman had already flagged as likely unconstitutional in 2025. This week's final order converts that preliminary finding into a statewide remediation mandate with a concrete completion date, putting pressure on a Legislature that has repeatedly declined to fund universal prison cooling while county jails must stay between 65 and 85 degrees.

Procedural history · TCURE v. Lumpkin

Eight days in Judge Pitman's court

2023

Class action filed in Western District of Texas

Advocates sue TDCJ leadership over summer heat exposure across the prison system.

2025

Preliminary ruling on likely Eighth Amendment violation

Pitman finds excessive heat likely unconstitutional but declines interim cooling orders pending full trial.

Mar 30 – Apr 9, 2026

Bench trial — eight days of testimony

Parties submit proposed findings in June; the court enters comprehensive findings September 22.

Sep 22, 2026

Statewide AC plan ordered

TDCJ must implement a plan immediately and finish installation by December 31, 2029.

Court of Criminal Appeals · Cameron County · Sep 24, 2026
5–4 Majority rejects habeas court innocence findings

Ex parte Lucio

Four years after a district judge declared Melissa Lucio actually innocent of capital murder in her daughter's 2007 death, a slim CCA majority declined to adopt any of the habeas court's findings — leaving Lucio's conviction and death sentence in place and setting up potential federal review. Four judges dissented, including opinions criticizing the majority for disregarding Cameron County prosecutors' concessions about withheld evidence.

The unsigned majority wrote that the lower court's conclusions "exclusively reflect Applicant's interpretation of the evidence and are often unsupported." No new execution date was set.

Election law · Tarrant County · Sep 24, 2026

Crystal Mason's provisional ballot saga ends

The Court of Criminal Appeals dismissed the State's petition for review as improvidently granted — letting stand the Fort Worth Second Court of Appeals decision that vacated Mason's 2018 illegal-voting conviction because prosecutors failed to prove she knew she was ineligible while on federal supervised release.

Prosecution position

Tarrant County DA Phil Sorrells argued multiple courts had found sufficient evidence of knowing illegal voting and that the Second Court misapplied the knowledge element.

CCA outcome

Majority: appeal improvidently granted; Mason will not serve the five-year sentence tied to a ballot that was never counted. Four judges filed dissents.

Family law · Comity · Sep 25, 2026

As a matter of law, the notice provided here is constitutionally inadequate, and far short of what our public policy demands. Other countries are welcome to conclude otherwise, but their judgments are not entitled to comity in a Texas court.

Azhar v. Choudhri · Texas Supreme Court · Sep 25, 2026

In a high-asset community-property dispute, the Court refused to recognize a Pakistani talaq divorce obtained through five days of newspaper publication that the wife never saw — reversing the Dallas Court of Appeals and remanding for proceedings on Texas marital property.

Appellate procedure · El Paso · Sep 23, 2026

When "final" is not final

The Eighth Court of Appeals dismissed an appeal for want of jurisdiction after a summary judgment labeled "final" failed to dispose of pleaded claims omitted from the motion — holding that a Mother Hubbard clause could not cure the defect without a severance order.

Judgment language

"Final" and "addresses all parties and claims" — but several causes of action never presented for summary judgment remained pending.

Eighth Court holding

Mother Hubbard did not adjudicate omitted claims; without severance, the judgment stayed interlocutory and the appeal was dismissed. Strong Builders, LLC v. CO3 Holdings, LLC, No. 08-25-00094-CV (Tex. App.—El Paso Sept. 23, 2026).

Energy & environment · Executive directive · Sep 21, 2026

TCEQ permit standstill for data centers

Governor Abbott directed TCEQ to halt all permits sought by data center projects until ERCOT completes its interconnection audit and TWDB finishes paired water-use review — extending the whole-of-government pause he began with PUC and TWDB orders in August and September.

Interim regulatory pipeline for new AI and crypto loads:

ERCOT queue audit TWDB water survey TCEQ permits frozen Oct 19 TCEQ report Mid-Dec ERCOT completion
89th Legislature · Interim charges

Capitol quiet, committees still working

Between regular sessions, House and Senate panels continued 89th-interim studies this week — teeing up bills for the January 2027 convening.

Sep 21, 2026

Senate Natural Resources — monitoring 89th water, parks, and coastal implementation legislation.

Sep 22, 2026

Senate Economic Development — hotel occupancy tax accountability, project finance zones, and AI workforce impacts.

By the numbers · Criminal justice week

Three courts, three outcomes

Prison AC mandate
Statewide
Lucio relief
5–4
Mason conviction
Vacated
Who this affects

Practice notes for the week

Civil rights & § 1983 litigators

Pitman's order creates a measurable compliance timeline — watch TDCJ's plan filings and any state appeal for standards on deliberate indifference in heat cases.

Appellate practitioners

Strong Builders reinforces that Mother Hubbard language cannot substitute for explicit claim disposition or a severance order before treating a summary judgment as appealable.

Family & international counsel

Azhar sets a high notice bar for recognizing foreign divorces when ordinary spousal communication channels remain open.

Energy & land-use developers

Data-center environmental permits remain frozen pending ERCOT/TWDB audits — budget contingency for Q4 2026 milestones and the October 19 TCEQ gubernatorial report.

The week ahead

Dates to watch

Sep 28 – Oct 2, 2026

House and Senate interim hearings resume — Business & Commerce transmission charges, Governmental Oversight prosecutorial policies, and Culture & Tourism charges on the calendar.

Oct 2, 2026 (typical)

Texas Supreme Court opinion release window during October term — monitor txcourts.gov for Friday orders.

Oct 19, 2026

TCEQ must report to the Governor's office on compliance with the data-center permit pause directive.

October 2026 (expected)

Travis County DTPA remedies trial in State v. TikTok — penalties phase after September liability ruling (monitor 250th District docket).

Mid-December 2026

ERCOT targeted completion of data-center interconnection audit — prerequisite to lifting TCEQ's permit freeze.

Federal follow-up

Lucio defense counsel signaled continued federal habeas litigation after the CCA's September 24 denial.

What is Legally Brief?